Americans in Germany: the money questions
Germany is the European country where an American's tax bill is decided by things that do not exist in the United States: an annual charge on fund holdings that were never sold, a flat settlement tax on investment income that collides with US capital gains rates, a church tax triggered by a line on a registration form, and an exit tax on company shareholdings that falls when you leave rather than when you sell. Earned income is usually fine. Everything around it is not.
- Vorabpauschale — Germany taxes a notional annual return on fund holdings even when nothing is sold, creating German tax in years the IRS does not recognise, so the credit is frequently stranded.
- Abgeltungsteuer — investment income is taxed at a flat 25% plus surcharges, an effective rate above the US long-term capital gains rate, which leaves unusable excess credit.
- US Social Security — under the treaty it is generally taxable only in Germany for a German resident, the opposite of most US treaties and of what almost every American expects.
- Wegzugsteuer — a 1% or greater shareholding in a corporation is treated as sold at market value when you give up German residence, with no matching US event to credit against.
German tax and residence
When Germany starts taxing you, how the treaty splits it, and the charges nobody warns you about.
- When do I become a German tax resident? — You become a German tax resident from the day you have a home available to you in Germany (Wohnsitz) or from the point you establish an habitual abode, generally continuous presence of more than six months. There is no 183-day grace period on arrival: signing a lease and registering with the Einwohnermeldeamt normally makes you resident immediately, and unlimited tax liability applies to worldwide income from that date.
- Do I pay tax twice if I live in Germany as an American? — You file in both countries and rarely pay full tax twice. Germany taxes residents on worldwide income at progressive rates reaching 42%, and 45% at the top band, so German tax on earned income normally exceeds US tax and the foreign tax credit removes the US liability. Double taxation survives mainly on investment income, where Germany's flat 25% settlement tax and US rules diverge, and on German charges the IRS will not credit.
- Do I have to pay German church tax as an American? — Only if you are registered as a member of a tax-collecting religious community in Germany. Church tax (Kirchensteuer) is 8% of your income tax in Bavaria and Baden-Württemberg and 9% elsewhere, withheld automatically from salary and from investment income. It is triggered by what you declare on your registration form at the town hall, not by attendance or belief.
- What is the German exit tax (Wegzugsteuer) and does it apply to me? — Wegzugsteuer under section 6 of the Foreign Tax Act treats a substantial shareholding in a corporation — generally 1% or more held at any point in the previous five years — as sold at market value when you give up unlimited German tax liability. Tax falls on gains never realised. From 2025 comparable exit taxation was extended to large holdings of investment fund units.
- How does German capital gains tax work for Americans? — Germany taxes investment income and capital gains at a flat 25% settlement tax plus the 5.5% solidarity surcharge on that tax, and church tax if you are registered — roughly 26.4% to 28% in total. An annual saver's allowance of €1,000 per person, €2,000 for a married couple filing jointly, is exempt. There is no long-term holding discount for securities, unlike US long-term capital gains rates of 15% or 20%.
Investing in Germany as a US citizen
The rules that make German fund investing expensive for an American — and how to keep access to US accounts.
- What is the Vorabpauschale and how does it affect Americans in Germany? — The Vorabpauschale is an advance lump-sum charge that taxes a notional minimum annual return on investment fund holdings even when nothing is sold and no distribution is made. It is calculated from a base rate set annually by the Bundesbank applied to 70% of the fund value at the start of the year, capped at the fund's actual gain, and taxed at the flat settlement rate.
- Are German funds and ETFs PFICs for an American? — Generally yes. German and other EU-domiciled funds, ETFs and unit-linked insurance investments are typically passive foreign investment companies for a US citizen. The default US regime taxes gains and excess distributions at the highest ordinary rates with an interest charge for deferral, and requires a separate Form 8621 for each fund held.
- Can I keep my Vanguard or Fidelity account while living in Germany? — Sometimes. US brokers differ: several restrict trading, block new purchases or close accounts once your registered address is outside the United States, while others maintain international accounts for US citizens abroad. German and EU brokers cannot generally sell you US-domiciled funds because EU disclosure rules require a local key information document, and EU-domiciled funds are PFICs for US tax purposes — which is why account access, not fund choice, is the first problem to solve.
Pensions, German and American
The 401(k), Roth, IRA and HSA under German rules, and whether German pension products are worth it.
- How is my 401(k) taxed if I live in Germany? — Withdrawals from a US 401(k) or IRA by a German resident are generally taxable in Germany under the pension article of the US–Germany treaty, at German progressive rates, with the United States retaining the right to tax its citizens and the foreign tax credit resolving the overlap. Roth withdrawals are the exception that hurts: tax-free in the United States leaves nothing to credit German tax against.
- How is my Roth IRA taxed in Germany? — A Roth IRA stays tax-free for US purposes, but Germany is not obliged to mirror that. Germany has no domestic Roth equivalent and the US–Germany treaty does not name the account by title, so the German treatment depends on whether your Finanzamt accepts the Roth as a pension under Article 18. If it does not, withdrawals — or in the worst reading, annual internal growth — can be taxed in Germany.
- Can I contribute to my IRA while living in Germany? — Yes, provided you have earned income that has not been excluded. IRA contributions require taxable compensation, so if the foreign earned income exclusion removes your entire German salary from US taxation there is nothing left to contribute against. Americans in Germany who claim foreign tax credits instead of the exclusion normally keep full IRA eligibility, and German tax rates are high enough that credits are usually the better choice anyway.
- What happens to my HSA when I move to Germany? — You keep the HSA and it remains tax-free for US purposes, but Germany does not recognise health savings accounts, so the income and gains inside it are generally treated as ordinary investment income and can be taxed in Germany each year. New contributions also stop, because contributing requires coverage under a qualifying US high-deductible health plan, which German statutory or private cover is not.
- How is my German company pension (bAV) taxed by the IRS? — German occupational pensions (betriebliche Altersversorgung) generally sit on firmer ground than private contracts because the US–Germany treaty contains specific provisions for pension schemes, but treatment depends on which of the five statutory vehicles your employer uses. Direktversicherung and Pensionskasse arrangements holding investment funds raise PFIC questions; unfunded Direktzusage promises usually do not.
- Is a Riester or Rürup pension worth it if I'm American? — Both deliver genuine German tax relief and both create US complications. Rürup (Basisrente) contributions are fully deductible for German income tax, which is valuable at a 42% marginal rate, but the IRS generally does not treat either contract as a qualified pension, so growth can be currently taxable and the underlying funds are typically PFICs requiring separate reporting.
Working, earning and housing
What German payroll takes, how health cover works, and buying or selling a home.
- How much of my German salary goes to social contributions? — Beyond income tax, a German employee pays social contributions of roughly 20% of gross salary up to annual ceilings, matched by the employer: pension insurance at 18.6% split between the two, health insurance at 14.6% plus a fund-specific supplement, long-term care insurance at around 3.4% with a surcharge for the childless, and unemployment insurance at 2.6%. Contributions stop above the ceilings, so effective rates fall as pay rises.
- How does German health insurance work for Americans? — Health insurance is compulsory for everyone resident in Germany. Most employees join the statutory system, where contributions are a percentage of income up to an annual ceiling, split with the employer, and non-earning spouses and children are covered at no extra cost. Higher earners above the threshold, the self-employed and many pensioners can opt for private cover, which is priced by age and health rather than income — and switching back later is difficult.
- Can I get a German mortgage as an American? — Yes. German banks lend to US citizens resident in Germany on broadly normal terms, typically up to 80% of value with a fixed rate for ten to fifteen years, while non-residents are usually limited to around 60%. Purchase costs are the bigger shock: property transfer tax of 3.5% to 6.5% depending on the federal state, plus notary and registration fees of roughly 1.5% to 2%.
- Should I sell my US house before moving to Germany? — Usually yes, if a sale is coming anyway. The US allows a main-home gain exclusion of $250,000 single or $500,000 married filing jointly, and Germany does not mirror it. Sell while still US resident and the gain can be entirely tax-free; sell after German residence begins and Germany may tax the gain at progressive rates with no US tax left to credit against it.
Retiring in Germany and what passes on
Social Security under the treaty, what retirement costs, German inheritance tax and wills.
- How does Germany tax my US Social Security? — Under the social security provision of the US–Germany treaty, US Social Security benefits paid to a resident of Germany are generally taxable only in Germany, not in the United States. Germany then applies its own partial-taxation rules for pension income. This is one of the few treaty outcomes that survives the US saving clause, so it genuinely removes the benefit from the US base for a German resident.
- How much money do I need to retire in Germany? — A couple retiring comfortably in a mid-sized German city typically needs somewhere between €45,000 and €70,000 a year before tax, with Munich, Frankfurt and Hamburg pushing well above that and smaller cities in the east well below. The variable Americans underestimate is health insurance: joining the statutory system in retirement is not automatic for an arriving foreign retiree.
- Do my heirs pay German inheritance tax? — Possibly. German inheritance tax is charged on the recipient rather than on the estate, and applies where the deceased or the heir is German resident, or where German-situated assets pass. Personal allowances run to €500,000 for a spouse and €400,000 per child, with rates from 7% to 50% depending on relationship and amount. A separate US–Germany estate and gift tax treaty governs the overlap.
- Do I need a German will if I already have a US will? — Usually yes, or at least a written election. Under the EU Succession Regulation, succession to the estate of someone habitually resident in Germany is governed by German law by default, including compulsory-share rights for a spouse and children. A US citizen may elect the law of their nationality instead, but the election must be made expressly in the will — silence means German law applies.