Do I need a German will if I already have a US will?
Short answer: Usually yes, or at least a written election. Under the EU Succession Regulation, succession to the estate of someone habitually resident in Germany is governed by German law by default, including compulsory-share rights for a spouse and children. A US citizen may elect the law of their nationality instead, but the election must be made expressly in the will — silence means German law applies.
Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.
Why it works this way
The regulation switched the default from nationality to habitual residence. An American who dies while living in Germany with only a US will has not chosen anything, so German succession law fills the gap.
German law gives close family a Pflichtteil, a compulsory monetary claim broadly equal to half the value of their intestate share. It cannot be disinherited away by a US will that says otherwise.
Married couples are also affected by the matrimonial property regime, which decides what is in the estate before succession law decides who gets it. A US couple who never thought about this are treated under the German default regime.
Practicalities matter as much as law. German banks, land registries and insurers want a German-recognised grant; a US probate order can take a long time and a lot of money to be accepted.
The expensive mistake: Signing a German will that quietly revokes the US one
Standard revocation wording in a German will can cancel a US will covering US property, and the reverse can happen too. The two documents must be drafted to sit alongside each other, each limited to its own assets, by lawyers in both countries who have read the other document.
What to do
- Make the choice-of-law election explicitly — If you want your US state law to govern, the will must say so. It is one clause and it changes the entire outcome.
- Keep German-situs assets under a German will — Property, bank accounts and a German company interest are far simpler to administer locally.
- Have both documents reviewed together — Estate documents are always drafted and executed by your attorney and local counsel — the planning job is making sure the two instruments agree.