Home › Ask

How does German capital gains tax work for Americans?

Short answer: Germany taxes investment income and capital gains at a flat 25% settlement tax plus the 5.5% solidarity surcharge on that tax, and church tax if you are registered — roughly 26.4% to 28% in total. An annual saver's allowance of €1,000 per person, €2,000 for a married couple filing jointly, is exempt. There is no long-term holding discount for securities, unlike US long-term capital gains rates of 15% or 20%.

Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.

Why it works this way

Because the German rate is higher than the US long-term rate, the foreign tax credit rarely produces a US refund; the excess German tax is simply a cost. Because the German rate is flat, holding for longer changes nothing in Germany even though it changes everything in the US.

Timing diverges too. Germany taxes the Vorabpauschale annually on funds you have not sold, then credits it on eventual sale. The US taxes only on sale. Tax paid in Germany years earlier cannot generally be credited against the US tax that finally arrives.

Losses are ring-fenced in Germany: losses on shares can generally only offset gains on shares, not other investment income. US loss rules are broader, so the two returns can disagree about whether you had a good year.

Real estate is the exception to the flat rate. A private property gain inside the ten-year holding period is taxed at your progressive rate; after ten years it is generally exempt in Germany while remaining fully taxable in the United States.

The expensive mistake: Assuming German tax paid always erases the US bill

It usually does on salary and rarely does cleanly on investments. Different rates, different timing and Germany's flat settlement tax leave residual US liabilities and stranded credits that only show up when someone reconciles the two returns side by side.

What to do

  1. Use the saver's allowance deliberately — File a Freistellungsauftrag with your bank so the €1,000 or €2,000 allowance is applied at source rather than reclaimed later.
  2. Realise large US gains before German residence starts — The split tax year on arrival makes this genuinely possible, not theoretical.
  3. Hold securities Germany taxes simply — Individual shares and bonds avoid the Vorabpauschale machinery that strands credits across tax years.
German versus US treatment of a securities gain
FeatureGermanyUnited States
Headline rate25% + 5.5% surcharge (+ church tax)0/15/20% long-term
Holding period benefitNone for securitiesLower rate after 12 months
Annual allowance€1,000 / €2,000 jointNone (0% band instead)
Tax before saleYes — Vorabpauschale on fundsNo
Loss offsetShare losses against share gainsBroader offset, $3,000 against income

Sources

Related questions

Book a call with Selanis