Home › Ask

How is my 401(k) taxed if I live in Germany?

Short answer: Withdrawals from a US 401(k) or IRA by a German resident are generally taxable in Germany under the pension article of the US–Germany treaty, at German progressive rates, with the United States retaining the right to tax its citizens and the foreign tax credit resolving the overlap. Roth withdrawals are the exception that hurts: tax-free in the United States leaves nothing to credit German tax against.

Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.

Why it works this way

Germany does not recognise the US tax character of these accounts. What matters for German purposes is the nature and timing of the payment, not the wrapper it came out of, and periodic payments and lump sums are not treated the same way.

Article 18A of the treaty is unusually helpful on the contribution side: it allows, within limits, contributions to a plan in one country to be recognised by the other for people working across the two. Very few US treaties contain anything comparable, and almost nobody uses it.

The Roth problem is structural. The United States charges nothing on a qualified Roth distribution, so the foreign tax credit has no US liability to offset and Germany's charge, if it applies, is paid in full. A Roth that was the right answer in Ohio can be the wrong answer in Munich.

A large lump sum can be worse than a series of payments, because German progressive rates reach 42% quickly and the top band applies from around €278,000 of taxable income. Spreading withdrawals across years is often worth more than any product decision.

The expensive mistake: Converting to a Roth after becoming German resident

The conversion is a taxable event in the United States and may be one in Germany too, and the future tax-free growth that justifies a conversion is a US concept Germany does not necessarily honour. Conversions belong to the last full US-resident year, before the German clock starts, not after.

What to do

  1. Model the withdrawal sequence across both rate schedules — German progressive rates and US brackets interact; the efficient order is rarely the obvious one.
  2. Decide the Roth question before you move, not after — Conversions and large Roth withdrawals are cheapest while you are still only a US taxpayer.
  3. Keep a running record of excess foreign tax credits — Credits generated by high German tax on salary can shelter later US-taxed withdrawals for up to ten years.

Sources

Related questions

Book a call with Selanis