Home › Ask

Do I pay tax twice if I live in Germany as an American?

Short answer: You file in both countries and rarely pay full tax twice. Germany taxes residents on worldwide income at progressive rates reaching 42%, and 45% at the top band, so German tax on earned income normally exceeds US tax and the foreign tax credit removes the US liability. Double taxation survives mainly on investment income, where Germany's flat 25% settlement tax and US rules diverge, and on German charges the IRS will not credit.

Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.

Why it works this way

German income tax is high enough on salary and pension income that the foreign tax credit usually absorbs the entire US bill and leaves excess credit carried forward for ten years. That is the good case, and for most employed Americans in Germany it is the normal outcome.

Investment income behaves differently. Germany applies Abgeltungsteuer, a flat settlement tax of 25% plus the solidarity surcharge and, if you are a registered church member, church tax — an effective rate of roughly 26.4% to 28%. US long-term capital gains taxed at 15% or 20% generate less US tax than that, so the excess German tax cannot be used, while short-term US-taxable items can leave a residual US bill.

The two systems tax different things at different moments. Germany's Vorabpauschale taxes an annual notional return on fund holdings that were never sold; the United States taxes on sale. Tax paid in one year on an event the other country does not recognise cannot be credited in the year the other country finally taxes it.

The treaty allocates by income type, and the results are not intuitive. US Social Security paid to a German resident is generally taxable only in Germany, the opposite of what most Americans expect, while Article 18A allows cross-border pension contributions to be recognised in ways most other US treaties do not.

The expensive mistake: Letting a German Steuerberater and a US preparer file in isolation

Each produces a correct return in its own system and the pair is wrong together. Credits get claimed in the wrong year, Vorabpauschale amounts are never surfaced to the US side, and church tax and solidarity surcharge are treated inconsistently. The coordination is the work, and it has to be done by someone looking at both returns at once.

What to do

  1. Separate earned income from investment income before your first German filing — Earned income is normally safe. Investment income is where the credit breaks, and it is the part you can restructure.
  2. Track excess foreign tax credit deliberately — Excess credits carry forward ten years and can shelter a later Roth conversion or a US-taxed lump sum — but only if someone records them.
  3. Price the non-creditable charges as a cost of living in Germany — Church tax and mismatched Abgeltungsteuer are a recurring annual cost, not tax you get back.
Where the credit works and where it breaks for Americans in Germany
Income typeGerman treatmentCredit against US tax?
SalaryProgressive to 42%, 45% top bandYes — usually more than enough
German pension incomeProgressive, partially taxable by cohortUsually yes
Dividends, interest, gains25% flat plus surchargesPartly — rate and timing mismatch
Vorabpauschale on fundsTaxed annually without a saleOften stranded in the wrong year
Church tax8–9% of income tax if registeredTreated inconsistently; often lost

Sources

Related questions

Book a call with Selanis