Should I sell my US house before moving to Germany?
Short answer: Usually yes, if a sale is coming anyway. The US allows a main-home gain exclusion of $250,000 single or $500,000 married filing jointly, and Germany does not mirror it. Sell while still US resident and the gain can be entirely tax-free; sell after German residence begins and Germany may tax the gain at progressive rates with no US tax left to credit against it.
Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.
Why it works this way
The US exclusion requires the property to have been your main home for two of the previous five years, so it survives a short period abroad — but the German charge arrives as soon as you are German tax resident on the sale date.
Germany taxes private property gains realised within a ten-year holding period, with an exemption where the property has been used as your own home in the year of sale and the two preceding years. A US house you have moved out of usually fails that test.
Germany does split the tax year on arrival, so the date of sale relative to the date your unlimited liability starts genuinely decides the outcome.
Keeping the house as a rental is a different decision with different mechanics: German tax on worldwide rental income with treaty relief, US depreciation recapture on eventual sale, and currency exposure on the mortgage.
The expensive mistake: Closing the sale a few weeks after registering in Germany
The paperwork slips, the closing moves, and a gain that would have been fully excluded lands inside the German tax year. This is the single most expensive timing error Americans make on a move to Germany, and it is entirely avoidable by fixing the residence start date around the closing rather than the other way round.
What to do
- Fix the closing date before you fix the lease date — Registration in Germany starts the clock; the sale should be finished first if you can arrange it.
- If you keep it, price the real cost — German tax on the rent, US depreciation recapture later, dollar rent against euro spending — it is rarely the passive income it looks like.
- Record the dollar cost basis and the exchange rates — Germany computes the gain in euro. A flat dollar result can be a euro gain, and vice versa.