How do we plan when only one of us is American?
Short answer: Carefully, because US rules follow the American spouse into a shared household. Joint accounts can pull a non-American spouse's money into US reporting, the non-American spouse's local investments are usually fine for them and PFICs for the couple's US return, and the election to treat a non-resident spouse as a US taxpayer is a decision with long consequences.
Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.
Why it works this way
The structural insight is that the US taxes people, not households, but bank accounts are held by households. A joint account with a non-American spouse can bring their balance into the American spouse's reporting, which is often the first unwelcome discovery a mixed couple makes.
The reverse also holds, and it is the useful part. Assets held solely by the non-American spouse generally sit outside the US system, which means that in many mixed households the efficient answer is not for both people to hold everything identically. Who owns what becomes a planning decision rather than an administrative default.
Electing to treat a non-resident spouse as a US taxpayer can reduce this year's bill and can be hard to unwind, drawing that spouse's worldwide income into the US system permanently for practical purposes. It is a decision worth modelling over a decade rather than a filing season.
There is a relationship dimension too, and it is not trivial. One partner carries paperwork, restrictions and costs the other does not, and decisions that look purely technical — whose name an account is in, who holds the investments — can feel like statements about trust. Naming that openly early usually prevents a much harder conversation later.
The expensive mistake: Defaulting to joint everything because that is what couples do
It is the natural instinct and frequently the wrong structure here. It expands US reporting over money that need not be inside it, and it can make the non-American spouse's ordinary local investments into a problem for the couple's return.
What to do
- Map who legally owns each account today — Sole, joint, or beneficially shared. Most couples have never written this down.
- Model the spousal election over ten years, not one — The short-term saving and the long-term cost frequently point in opposite directions.
- Agree the structure together, out loud — Separate ownership for tax reasons is a technical decision. It only works if both people understand why it exists.