Home › Ask

Will I pay an exit tax when I leave a European country to move back to the US?

Short answer: Several European countries tax departing residents on unrealised gains. Germany deems a shareholding of 1% or more sold at market value on departure, the Netherlands issues protective assessments on substantial interests and pension rights, and Spain charges departing holders of large shareholdings. Ordinary diversified portfolios usually escape. The problem for Americans is that there is no matching US sale, so the foreign tax is difficult or impossible to credit.

Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.

Why it works this way

Exit taxes exist because a country that has watched a gain accrue under its own tax system does not want to lose the right to tax it when the owner leaves. They therefore attach to concentrated, locally accrued value — a stake in a company, a substantial interest, accrued pension rights — rather than to a diversified brokerage account.

Germany's Wegzugsteuer under section 6 of the Außensteuergesetz treats a shareholding of 1% or more in a corporation as sold at fair market value when German residence ends, and the 2025 extension brought large holdings in investment funds within scope. There is no sale in US terms, so no US gain arises in that year, and the German tax has nothing to sit against.

The Netherlands uses a different mechanism: a conserverende aanslag, a protective assessment issued on departure covering substantial interests and accrued pension and annuity rights. It is not collected immediately and can lapse after a period without a triggering event, but it constrains what you can do with those rights for years afterwards, and cashing in a Dutch pension after leaving can make it payable.

The US side is the part that gets mishandled. The foreign tax credit matches foreign tax to US income of the same type in the same year. A departure charge on an unrealised gain generates foreign tax in a year with no corresponding US income, and by the time the asset is actually sold — possibly years later, as a US resident — the foreign tax is long gone. Planning means moving the real disposal to where it can meet the credit, or accepting the cost with eyes open.

The expensive mistake: Assuming a diversified portfolio is at risk, and a company stake is not

It is usually the other way round. The ordinary brokerage account and the index funds are typically untouched by exit charges, while the founder shareholding, the family company stake, the substantial interest in a BV or GmbH, and the accrued occupational pension are exactly what the rules target. People spend planning effort on the wrong assets and discover the real exposure in the final filing.

What to do

  1. List every holding of 1% or more in any company, anywhere — Including private companies, family holdings and employer equity. These are the assets exit charges attach to.
  2. Ask whether disposing before departure is cheaper than being deemed to dispose — A real sale while resident produces foreign tax and a US gain in the same year, which is creditable. A deemed sale on departure often does not.
  3. Check whether a protective assessment constrains what you can do afterwards — Dutch protective assessments in particular can turn a later pension decision into an immediate liability.
Departure charges by country, in outline
CountryWhat triggers itTypical exposure
GermanyShareholding of 1%+ deemed sold on departureFounders, employees with large stakes
NetherlandsProtective assessment on substantial interest and pension rightsBV owners, accrued Dutch pensions
SpainDeparture charge on large shareholdings above statutory thresholdsConcentrated holdings only
FranceCharge on substantial holdings, with deferral availableCompany stakes above thresholds
ItalyNo general individual exit tax on securitiesLow
SwitzerlandNo exit tax, but Pillar 2 decisions crystallisePension capital decision

Sources

Related questions

Book a call with Selanis