What happens to my foreign employer shares and stock options when I move back to the US?
Short answer: Equity earned abroad is generally sourced to where you worked during the period it was earned, not to where you live when it vests. An RSU granted in Germany and vesting after you return is usually part-German, part-US income, and both countries may withhold. Options exercised after departure and shareholdings above local thresholds can also trigger exit charges.
Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.
Why it works this way
Most countries and the United States apportion equity compensation over the vesting or earning period by workdays in each jurisdiction. A four-year RSU grant made two years before you move is broadly half foreign-source and half US-source. That apportionment determines which country taxes what, and it rarely matches what either payroll actually withholds.
Withholding is the practical problem. The foreign employer's payroll often withholds in full on the whole vest because the grant originated there, while the US employer or broker withholds on the US portion. The result is over-withholding in one country, under-withholding in the other, and a credit claim that only works if the apportionment is documented at the time.
Exercise timing changes the answer materially. Exercising options while still foreign resident usually puts the spread into the foreign system, where rates may be higher or lower and where the foreign tax is creditable. Exercising after you land puts it into the US system with no foreign tax to credit, but possibly at long-term rates depending on the plan type. Neither is universally better — it is a calculation with a deadline.
Concentrated shareholdings are where exit taxes attach. A 1% or greater stake in a German corporation, a substantial interest in a Dutch BV, or a large holding subject to Spanish or French departure rules, can be deemed sold on departure. For employees of private companies and founders, this is frequently the single largest number in the entire move.
The expensive mistake: Letting payroll decide, then trying to fix it in the tax returns
Equity apportionment is something you document while it is happening — workdays by jurisdiction, grant and vest dates, exercise dates, exchange rates used. Reconstructed a year later from two payslips and a broker statement, it is usually impossible to support, and the default outcome is paying the higher of the two countries with a credit that only partly lands.
What to do
- Build a workday record by country for every unvested grant — Grant date, vest date, and days worked in each jurisdiction in between. This single spreadsheet is the whole defence.
- Decide exercise timing against your residence date, not your comfort — Model the exercise in the final foreign year and the first US year before deciding.
- Check whether any holding crosses a local exit-tax threshold — One per cent of a corporation is a low bar, and private company stakes cross it regularly.
Sources
- Publication 519 — U.S. Tax Guide for Aliens (residency rules)
- Foreign Tax Credit
- Federal Ministry of Finance — taxation