What is Italy's flat tax for new residents, and can an American use it?
Short answer: Italy's regime under Article 24-bis lets individuals who become Italian tax resident after at least nine of the previous ten years abroad pay a fixed annual substitute tax on all foreign-source income, instead of Italian tax at ordinary rates, for up to fifteen years. The fixed amount was €100,000 and was raised to €200,000 for those transferring residence after 10 August 2024, with a lower fixed amount available per family member.
Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.
Why it works this way
The attraction is simple: once elected, foreign income of any size is covered by the fixed annual payment, so someone with large portfolio income, foreign business income or substantial foreign capital gains can cap their Italian bill. Italian-source income stays taxable normally, and the election is made through a ruling process with the Agenzia delle Entrate.
For a US citizen the arithmetic changes fundamentally. The substitute tax is a fixed amount, not a rate applied to income, and its interaction with the US foreign tax credit is not the clean offset that ordinary Italian income tax provides. Paying a flat sum to Italy does not reliably reduce the US bill on the same income, so the American can end up funding both.
That does not make it useless — it makes the break-even much higher. Where the regime works for an American is where Italian tax at ordinary rates would be enormous and US tax on the same income would be comparatively small: substantial foreign income that the United States taxes lightly or not at all, or income streams where US rates are far below Italian marginal rates plus surcharges.
The regime also excludes certain items in the early years — capital gains on qualifying shareholdings disposed of within the first five years are outside the substitute tax — and it carries reporting consequences. Electing in does not remove US obligations: FBAR, FATCA reporting, PFIC filings and the full 1040 all continue.
The expensive mistake: Electing because it is famous, without running the US side
This regime was designed for wealthy non-Americans, and almost all the advice written about it assumes that reader. An American who elects and then finds the fixed payment produces little or no US credit has bought an expensive Italian benefit and kept the full US bill. Run both returns side by side, on your real numbers, before the ruling request goes in.
What to do
- Check eligibility before anything else — The nine-of-ten-years-abroad condition is absolute. A recent stint of Italian residence disqualifies you regardless of everything else.
- Model both countries at once, across fifteen years — Compare the fixed Italian payment plus the resulting US bill against ordinary Italian tax plus the credits it would generate.
- Decide the family-member extension separately — The reduced amount per family member has its own break-even, and adding a spouse is not automatically worthwhile.
| Feature | Position |
|---|---|
| Eligibility | Non-resident for at least 9 of the previous 10 years |
| Annual substitute tax | €200,000 for transfers of residence after 10 August 2024 (€100,000 before) |
| Family members | Reduced fixed amount per additional family member |
| Maximum duration | Up to 15 years |
| Covers | Foreign-source income; Italian-source income taxed normally |
| US obligations | Unchanged — 1040, FBAR, FATCA and PFIC filings all continue |
Sources
- Individuals transferring their residence to Italy — tax regimes
- Agenzia delle Entrate — English portal