Home › Ask

Do I pay tax twice if I live in Italy as an American?

Short answer: You file in both countries, but you rarely pay full tax twice. Italy taxes residents on worldwide income; the United States taxes citizens wherever they live. The US–Italy income tax treaty and the foreign tax credit are designed to eliminate the overlap. Double taxation survives mainly where Italy charges a tax the United States will not credit, such as IVIE and IVAFE.

Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.

Why it works this way

Italian personal income tax (IRPEF) runs on progressive national bands with regional and municipal surcharges added on top, so effective Italian rates on employment and pension income are typically higher than US federal rates at the same income. When Italian tax exceeds US tax on the same income, the foreign tax credit normally wipes out the US liability and leaves excess credit carried forward.

Investment income breaks that pattern. Italy taxes most financial income — dividends, interest, capital gains — at a flat substitute rate of 26%, with Italian and EU government bonds taxed at 12.5%. Those flat rates sit differently against US rates, and long-term US capital gains taxed at 15% or 20% can produce Italian tax the credit does not fully absorb, or US tax the Italian payment does not cover.

The treaty allocates taxing rights by income type rather than giving either country priority overall. Employment income, pension income, real property income and government service pensions are each handled by their own article, and the answer for a state teacher's pension is not the answer for a 401(k) withdrawal. The saving clause preserves the United States' right to tax its citizens regardless, subject to specific exceptions.

The genuine residue of double taxation sits in the wealth-style taxes. IVIE on foreign real estate and IVAFE on foreign financial assets are levied on the value of what you own, not on income. Value taxes generally do not generate a US foreign tax credit against income tax, so for most Americans they are a straight additional cost of Italian residence.

The expensive mistake: Assuming an Italian commercialista and a US preparer will coordinate

They almost never do, and the two returns are filed months apart on different calendars. The Italian return is prepared without regard to US consequences, the US return is prepared from whatever figures arrive, and credits get claimed in the wrong year or not at all. The coordination — matching income to the right year and the right treaty article — is the work, and nobody does it unless somebody is hired to.

What to do

  1. Split your income by treaty article before your first Italian filing season — Employment, pension, US Social Security, rental, dividends and gains are each allocated differently. One list, prepared once, prevents years of mismatched credits.
  2. Check whether your credits actually land in the same year — Italy and the United States both use a calendar year, which helps, but withholding, payment dates and accrued versus paid elections still shift credits between years.
  3. Price IVIE and IVAFE as an unrecoverable annual cost — Treat them as a residence cost rather than as tax you will get back, and decide how assets are held with that in mind.
Where double taxation genuinely bites for Americans in Italy
Income or assetItalian treatmentCredit against US tax?
Employment incomeIRPEF at progressive rates plus surchargesYes — usually more than enough
Most dividends, interest, gains26% flat substitute taxPartly — rate mismatch is common
Italian and EU government bonds12.5% flatUsually yes
Foreign real estate (IVIE)Annual charge on property valueGenerally not creditable
Foreign financial assets (IVAFE)Annual charge on asset valueGenerally not creditable

Sources

Related questions

Book a call with Selanis