Home › Ask

What does it mean that an adviser is paid only by clients?

Short answer: It means the adviser's only income comes from you, not from the products they recommend. That removes the structural incentive to recommend a commission-paying offshore plan over a low-cost portfolio. It matters most in expat advice, where commission-based distribution is unusually common and unusually expensive.

Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-07.

Why it works this way

Incentives shape recommendations even among honest people. An adviser paid a large up-front commission on a twenty-five-year savings plan is not necessarily dishonest for recommending one, but they will never recommend the alternative that pays them nothing, and you will never hear about it.

The expat market is particularly exposed because clients are mobile, often outside their home regulator's protection, and hard to follow up. That combination has historically supported a distribution model built on long lock-ins and front-loaded commission.

The test is not the label an adviser uses. It is what happens to their income depending on what you do. Ask directly, and ask for the answer in cash rather than percentages.

There is a middle category worth recognising, because it is where most confusion lives: an adviser who charges you a fee and also receives something from a provider — a trail, a platform rebate, a referral payment. That is not the same arrangement as being paid only by clients, and the difference only shows up if you ask the question in those words.

Being paid by clients does not by itself make advice good. It removes one specific distortion. Competence in your particular cross-border situation, and whether anyone owns the whole picture rather than half of it, still matter at least as much.

The expensive mistake: Assuming 'no fee' means low cost

Advice presented as free is the most expensive kind in this market. The cost is inside the product: establishment charges, ongoing policy charges, fund charges, and an exit penalty if you change your mind. Nothing appears on an invoice, which is precisely the point.

What to do

  1. Ask what they earn if you say yes, and if you say no — One question, and it resolves most of these conversations.
  2. Ask for total cost in cash over twenty years — Every charge, in currency, on a single line. Then compare across advisers.
  3. Check who holds the assets — A recognised custodian in your own name is a different proposition from a policy wrapper you cannot exit cheaply.
  4. Ask what it costs to leave, today and in year five — A charge for walking away is the clearest signal that somebody was paid up front for your future.

Related questions

Book a call with Selanis