Someone offered me an offshore savings plan. Is it a good idea?
Short answer: Usually not. The long-term savings and unit-linked insurance plans marketed to expats typically carry high layered charges, long commitment periods and heavy penalties for stopping early — and for US taxpayers the underlying funds are generally PFICs. A low-cost diversified portfolio does the same job for a fraction of the cost.
Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.
Why it works this way
The economics of these products are built around commission paid up front. That is why the commitment period is long, why the early-exit penalty is severe, and why the salesperson is enthusiastic. None of that is illegal; it is simply a distribution model in which the adviser's payment and your outcome are not aligned.
The charges are layered and hard to see individually: an establishment charge, an ongoing policy charge, fund charges underneath, sometimes a bid-offer spread, occasionally an advice fee on top. Any one looks small. Compounded over twenty years they can consume a very large share of what you would otherwise have.
For an American there is an extra layer. The funds inside are almost always non-US domiciled, so you own PFICs inside a wrapper that makes them harder to identify, report and exit.
The expensive mistake: Judging it by the illustration rather than the charges
The projection in the brochure shows a growing line. It does not show what the same contributions would have done in a low-cost portfolio, which is the only comparison that matters. Ask for both lines on the same chart and the conversation ends quickly.
What to do
- Ask what the adviser is paid in each scenario — If you sign, and if you do not. The answer is informative in itself.
- Ask for total cost in cash over twenty years — Not a percentage. A currency figure, all charges included.
- If you already hold one, get it analysed before surrendering — Sometimes exiting is right despite the penalty; sometimes it is better to make it paid-up. That depends on numbers, not principle.