What do I do with my foreign pension when I move back to the US?
Short answer: In most cases you keep it where it is. Foreign pensions generally cannot be rolled into a US IRA or 401(k), and cashing one in on departure often produces a large, locally taxed payment in a single year. Once you are a US resident, the treaty usually gives the United States the right to tax withdrawals, with a credit for any foreign withholding, and the pension remains a reportable foreign account.
Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.
Why it works this way
There is no international rollover. A 401(k) can move to an IRA because both are US-recognised plans; an Irish PRSA, a Swiss Pillar 2 or a Dutch occupational pension has no route into the US system. Anyone offering to transfer a foreign pension into a US arrangement is almost always proposing a taxable encashment with a product attached.
The treaty position flips when you move. While you were resident abroad, the treaty usually gave the foreign country taxing rights over your local pension. Once you are a US resident, the pension article typically allocates taxation of periodic payments to your country of residence — the United States — with the foreign country retaining limited or no rights. That is generally favourable, but only if you claim it properly on the foreign side so withholding stops or is reduced.
Lump sums are treated differently from periodic payments in most treaties, and often much less favourably. A pension you draw as income may be taxed only in the United States, while the same pot taken as a lump sum can be taxed in the source country first, at a rate the US credit does not fully absorb. This is why the encashment decision has to be taken before, not after, the treaty position changes.
The reporting never stops. A foreign pension is generally reportable on the FBAR and frequently on Form 8938, and where the underlying investments are foreign funds, PFIC questions can arise depending on how the arrangement is structured. None of that is fatal, but it has a compliance cost every year, which belongs in the keep-or-encash decision.
The expensive mistake: Cashing in a modest foreign pension on the way out because it seems tidy
A €150,000 pot encashed in the final resident year is taxed locally at the top marginal rate in a year when your other income is already high, converted at one day's exchange rate, and lands in a US return that may credit only part of it. Left in place and drawn as income across retirement, the same pot is usually taxed once, at lower US rates, on your schedule. Tidiness is an expensive reason.
What to do
- Get a scheme statement and the rules in writing before you leave — Payment options, minimum ages, currency of payment and whether the provider will pay to a US address. Some will not, and that changes the decision.
- Model lump sum against income under both treaty positions — Once as a local resident, once as a US resident. The gap is often the largest single number in a repatriation plan.
- Fix the withholding before the first payment — Filing the residence certificate or treaty claim with the foreign provider early avoids years of over-withholding and reclaim paperwork.
| Vehicle | Transferable to a US plan? | Usual sensible answer |
|---|---|---|
| Irish PRSA or ARF | No | Keep, draw as income, claim treaty relief |
| Swiss Pillar 2 | No | Decision forced at departure — model both routes |
| Swiss Pillar 3a | No | Usually must be closed on leaving Switzerland |
| Dutch occupational pension | No | Keep; watch any protective assessment |
| German bAV or Rürup | No | Keep; encashment options are limited anyway |
| UK or other frozen scheme | No | Keep, review currency and drawdown age |
Sources
- United States income tax treaties A to Z
- Publication 519 — U.S. Tax Guide for Aliens (residency rules)