Is assurance-vie a problem for Americans in France?
Short answer: Yes, usually a serious one. Assurance-vie is the standard French savings and succession wrapper, and its tax advantages exist only under French law. The IRS does not recognise the wrapper, so the underlying funds are typically taxed as PFICs, the contract may carry additional US reporting obligations, and gains the French system shelters can be fully taxable in the US.
Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.
Why it works this way
Nearly every French bank, insurer and conseiller will recommend assurance-vie, and for a French national it is genuinely excellent: tax-deferred growth, favourable rates after eight years, and powerful succession treatment outside the normal inheritance rules. None of that binds the IRS.
The US looks through the wrapper to what is inside it. A typical assurance-vie holds unités de compte — French or Luxembourg collective funds — which are Passive Foreign Investment Companies for US purposes. PFIC taxation spreads gains back over the holding period at the highest ordinary rates with an interest charge, and requires a Form 8621 for each fund. Depending on the contract's structure there can be further US reporting obligations, and some arrangements raise foreign trust questions with their own heavy penalty regime.
The eight-year advantage that makes assurance-vie compelling in France actively works against an American, because the longer the contract runs, the worse the PFIC interest charge on eventual disposal becomes. The product's core benefit and its US cost both grow with time.
Even the succession advantage is asymmetric. The favourable French treatment on death does not change the US estate or income tax position, and the mismatch can leave heirs with a US tax event on a contract the French side treats as efficiently transferred.
The expensive mistake: Opening one because the bank required it to get the mortgage
French banks frequently bundle an assurance-vie or similar product with a mortgage offer, and Americans sign because the property purchase depends on it. This is the most common way US taxpayers end up owning one without ever deciding to. Push back — a term life policy or a pledged deposit will often satisfy the bank — and if you already hold one, get it assessed before it compounds for another few years.
What to do
- Find out what is actually inside the contract — A fonds en euros behaves differently from unités de compte. Get the full list of underlying holdings and their domiciles before deciding anything.
- Have the US reporting position assessed, not guessed — PFIC forms, and in some structures additional reporting, may be due for years already filed. Establish the exposure before it compounds further.
- Decide deliberately between exiting and holding — Surrendering triggers the PFIC charge now; holding grows it. There is no universally right answer, but there is a right answer for your contract, timeline and bracket.