Home › Ask

Are Italian investment funds PFICs for an American?

Short answer: Generally yes. Italian and other EU-domiciled collective investment funds and ETFs are typically passive foreign investment companies for US tax purposes, which means punitive taxation of gains and distributions under the default regime, plus a Form 8621 filing for each fund held. Italian banks and promoters recommend them routinely, because for an Italian taxpayer they are entirely sensible.

Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.

Why it works this way

The PFIC rules were written to stop Americans deferring tax through offshore funds, and they apply mechanically to ordinary retail funds sold in Europe. Nothing about an Italian equity fund is aggressive or exotic; it simply falls inside the definition, and the default excess distribution regime taxes gains at the highest ordinary rates with an interest charge for deferral.

The alternative elections that soften the treatment depend on information European funds rarely provide. A qualified electing fund election requires an annual statement in a specific US format that most Italian funds do not produce, and a mark-to-market election requires the fund to be regularly traded on a qualifying exchange. Neither can be assumed.

Italian banks and insurance distributors will present funds and unit-linked policies as the standard solution for an affluent client, and for a non-American they usually are: the Italian 26% substitute tax on financial income is straightforward and the products are efficient within it. The conflict is not misconduct, it is a different rulebook.

The workable answer for most Americans in Italy is to hold US-domiciled funds and ETFs in a US-based account and keep Italian holdings to direct securities and cash. That collides with the separate problem that Italian and other European institutions often decline US clients, and with Italy's asset-value charges — which is why the account architecture is usually decided before the portfolio is.

The expensive mistake: Buying an Italian unit-linked or insurance-wrapped product

These are sold hard to arriving foreigners as tax-efficient and estate-friendly, and they are among the worst structures an American can own: the underlying funds are typically PFICs, the wrapper adds foreign trust or insurance reporting questions, and exit charges make unwinding expensive. It is far easier to decline one than to dismantle one.

What to do

  1. Do not buy any pooled Italian or EU fund before the PFIC position is checked — A single purchase creates annual filings that persist for as long as the holding does.
  2. Keep the investment portfolio US-domiciled where you can — US ETFs and funds held in a US account avoid PFIC treatment entirely. Access and custodian policy decide feasibility.
  3. Audit any European funds you already hold — Establish the exposure from prior years before adding to it, and weigh disposal timing against residence dates.

Sources

Related questions

Book a call with Selanis