Should I sell my foreign funds before or after I move?
Short answer: It depends which country will tax the sale and what your income looks like in each year. The US charge on a PFIC disposal grows the longer the position is held, so delay is rarely free — but selling in the year you arrive somewhere new can expose the same gain to a local tax that would not have applied a year earlier or later. The order and the year are the whole decision.
Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.
Why it works this way
The US side has a built-in clock. The punitive default regime allocates gain across the holding period and adds an interest charge, so each additional year of holding raises the eventual cost. That argues for exiting sooner rather than later, all else equal.
All else is rarely equal, because the local side has its own timing. Some countries tax residents on worldwide gains from day one of residence; some have arrival reliefs; some tax on remittance. A sale that is straightforward before a move can become a second taxable event after it.
Your own income shape in each year matters as much as the rules. A year with a low taxable income — a gap between jobs, a partial year of work, the year of the move itself — is usually the cheapest window for a disposal in either system.
Finally the exit has to lead somewhere. Selling a PFIC without a decided replacement leaves the proceeds in cash, often in the wrong currency, for months. The reinvestment plan should exist before the sale instruction does.
The expensive mistake: Waiting until after the move because it feels tidier
People plan to 'sort out the investments once we've settled in'. That single decision can add a local tax charge on top of the US one, and adds another year to the US interest calculation. The cheapest window is often the one before residence begins.
What to do
- Fix your residence start date in each country first — Everything about sequencing depends on which side of that date a sale falls.
- Rank positions by size of embedded gain and holding period — The oldest, largest holdings carry the most accumulated cost and usually go first.
- Decide the replacement portfolio before you sell anything — US-domiciled, in the right currency, with the custody arrangement already open.