Which US state should I move back to after living abroad?
Short answer: Choose the state before you book the move, because the state you land in taxes your foreign pension withdrawals, your exit-year income and any post-arrival stock sale, and no treaty protects you from it. Nine states levy no broad income tax; several others aggressively claim returning former residents. In-state tuition clocks and property tax regimes should be weighed alongside the income tax rate.
Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.
Why it works this way
US tax treaties bind the federal government, not the states. A treaty article that stops a foreign country taxing your pension does nothing about California or New York, and several states do not recognise the foreign tax credit at all. Foreign-source income that was comfortably sheltered federally can be fully taxed at state level.
Some states are difficult to leave and easy to re-enter. California, New York, New Mexico, South Carolina and Virginia are known for treating a former resident as still domiciled where ties persisted — a property, a licence, a voter registration, family. An American who moved abroad without breaking those ties may never have stopped being a state resident, and returning to the same state confirms it.
The first year back is usually your highest-income year in a decade: a relocation package, a signing bonus, a pension lump sum, a property sale, accumulated equity vesting. Landing that year in a 0% state rather than a 10% state is frequently worth more than every other repatriation decision combined, and it is decided by where the lease is signed.
Non-tax factors deserve equal weight and are often decisive in practice. In-state tuition typically requires around twelve months of residency before enrolment, which sets a deadline if a child is close to college. Property tax, insurance cost and healthcare network quality vary far more between states than income tax rates do at moderate incomes.
The expensive mistake: Moving back to the state you left, without checking whether you ever stopped being resident there
If the old state still considers you domiciled, the years abroad may be assessable, not just the year you return. That is a much larger problem than the current year's rate, and it typically surfaces when a state matches a new address against an old file. Establishing clearly whether residency was broken — and documenting it — comes before choosing where to land.
What to do
- Determine whether you ever broke residency with your former state — Ties, filings and the paperwork at the time decide this. It is the first question, not the last.
- Run the first-year income through two or three candidate states — Include the pension lump sum, relocation payments, equity vesting and any property sale. The gap is usually large.
- Check the in-state tuition clock if children are near college age — Around twelve months of residency before enrolment is typical, which can move the whole timeline forward.
| Item | Federal position | State position |
|---|---|---|
| Foreign pension income | Treaty may limit foreign tax | Generally fully taxable, no treaty relief |
| Foreign tax credit | Available | Not recognised in many states |
| Exit-year bonus or lump sum | Ordinary income | Taxed by the state of residence when received |
| Foreign property sale | Section 121 may apply | Usually follows federal, but not always |
| In-state tuition | Not applicable | Typically twelve months residency |