Americans in Spain: the money questions
Spain is the European country where an American's outcome depends most on which region they choose. Wealth tax is set by each autonomous community, so Madrid rebates it entirely while Valencia and Cataluña charge it. On top of that sit Modelo 720 asset reporting, the Beckham Law election, and the fact that Spanish and EU funds are PFICs for US tax purposes, including on a traspaso switch Spain itself treats as tax-free.
- Regional wealth tax — the same portfolio can be taxed at zero in Madrid and at up to roughly 3.5% in another community, on worldwide net wealth above the allowances.
- Modelo 720 — Spanish residents must declare foreign accounts, securities and property where any category exceeds €50,000. It is a reporting duty, not a tax.
- The traspaso trap — Spain treats a switch between funds as tax-free; the IRS treats it as a sale, which can trigger punitive PFIC tax on gains Spain never taxed.
- The Beckham Law — a flat 24% on employment income for six years, which for a US citizen can reduce Spanish tax so far that the United States collects the difference.
Spanish tax and residence
When Spain starts taxing you, and how the treaty divides it with the IRS.
- Do I pay tax twice if I live in Spain as an American? — You file in both countries, but you rarely pay full tax twice. The US–Spain tax treaty and the US foreign tax credit let Spanish tax paid offset US tax owed on the same income. Real double taxation survives in three places: pooled investment funds, some pension withdrawals, and Spanish wealth tax, which has no US equivalent to credit against.
- When do I become a Spanish tax resident? — You become Spanish tax resident for a full calendar year if any one of three tests is met: you spend more than 183 days in Spain during the year, your main centre of economic interests is in Spain, or your non-separated spouse and dependent minor children habitually reside in Spain. Spanish residence is all-or-nothing for the year — there is no split-year treatment as there is in some countries.
- Can I use the Beckham Law as an American moving to Spain? — Yes, Americans can elect Spain's special expatriate regime, commonly called the Beckham Law, if they move to Spain for work and have not been Spanish tax resident in the preceding years. It taxes employment income at a flat 24% up to €600,000 and exempts most non-Spanish income from Spanish tax for six tax years. For US citizens the catch is that lower Spanish tax means fewer foreign tax credits, so the US collects the difference.
Reporting and wealth tax
The two filings that catch Americans in Spain out most often.
- What is Modelo 720 and do I have to file it? — Modelo 720 is an informational declaration of assets held outside Spain. Spanish tax residents must file it if any one of three categories — foreign bank accounts, foreign securities and investments, or foreign real estate — exceeds €50,000 in total value. It is reporting only, not a tax. For Americans it typically captures US bank accounts, brokerage accounts, IRAs and 401(k)s, and any US property.
- Do I have to report my 401(k) on Modelo 720? — Usually yes in substance, though the category it falls into depends on how the account is structured. Modelo 720 requires Spanish residents to declare foreign accounts, securities and real estate above the reporting threshold, and a US retirement account generally sits within that universe. The safe approach is to list every US asset and let your Spanish adviser decide the category, rather than deciding yourself that a pension is exempt.
- Do I pay Spanish wealth tax as an American? — Probably, depending on where in Spain you live and how much you own. Spanish tax residents are liable on worldwide net wealth above a general allowance of €700,000 per person, plus an additional allowance of up to €300,000 on a main residence. Rates are set by each autonomous community: Madrid and Andalucía apply a full rebate, while Cataluña, Valencia and others charge from roughly 0.2% to 3.5%.
Investing, equity and retirement accounts
Spanish funds, PFIC exposure, RSUs and what happens to the 401(k).
- Are Spanish investment funds PFICs for Americans? — Almost always yes. Spanish fondos de inversión, SICAVs and EU-domiciled ETFs are pooled foreign investment vehicles, which makes them Passive Foreign Investment Companies for US tax purposes. That triggers punitive US taxation, annual Form 8621 filing per fund, and — uniquely in Spain — a trap around traspaso, the switch between funds that Spain treats as tax-free but the IRS treats as a sale.
- How is my 401(k) taxed if I live in Spain? — A 401(k) can stay exactly where it is when you move to Spain and continues to grow tax-deferred. Withdrawals are generally taxable in Spain once you are Spanish tax resident, at progressive rates as employment-type income rather than at savings rates, with US foreign tax credit relief applied. Spain's treatment of the untouched balance for wealth tax purposes is less settled and needs specific advice.
- How are my US stock options and RSUs taxed if I live in Spain? — Spain generally taxes restricted stock units as employment income when they vest, while the United States taxes the portion of the award considered earned during US workdays. Because both countries can tax the same grant on different timetables, the foreign tax credit only works properly if the sourcing of each tranche is calculated grant by grant.
Retiring in Spain and what passes on
What it costs, where to base yourself, and the regional inheritance question.
- How much money do I need to retire in Spain as an American? — For most American couples, a comfortable retirement in Spain runs somewhere between roughly €2,500 and €4,500 a month depending heavily on region, which implies an invested portfolio in the region of $900,000 to $1.6 million at a 4% withdrawal rate, before tax. Spain is meaningfully cheaper than coastal America on housing and healthcare, and meaningfully more expensive on tax for wealthier households.
- Is Madrid or Valencia better for an American, financially? — Valencia is significantly cheaper to live in — housing typically runs 35% to 50% below Madrid for equivalent quality. Madrid is significantly cheaper to own assets in, because it applies a full rebate on regional wealth tax while Valencia levies it with a lower-than-standard allowance. Below roughly €1 million of net wealth Valencia usually wins; above it, Madrid frequently does.
- Is Spain or Portugal better for US retirees? — Neither is universally better. Spain is usually decided at regional level, where wealth tax and inheritance tax vary enormously between autonomous communities, while Portugal's answer turns on which residence regime you qualify for and how your pension income is characterised. For most American retirees the deciding factors are healthcare access, family proximity and how each country treats the assets they already hold.
- Will my heirs pay Spanish inheritance tax? — Possibly, and the answer depends almost entirely on the region. Spanish succession tax (Impuesto sobre Sucesiones y Donaciones) is charged to each recipient rather than to the estate, with rates and reliefs set by each autonomous community. Madrid, Andalucía and several others apply reliefs of around 99% for spouses and children; others charge substantially. Critically, there is no US–Spain estate tax treaty.