Is Italy or Portugal better for US retirees?
Short answer: Neither is universally better; they fail in different places. Portugal offers simpler geography, wide English use and no annual tax on financial assets, but the non-habitual residence regime that attracted retirees has been withdrawn for new arrivals. Italy still offers targeted flat-tax routes, including a 7% regime tied to small southern municipalities, but charges IVIE and IVAFE annually on foreign-held assets.
Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.
Why it works this way
The regimes point in opposite directions. Portugal's advantage was a broad national regime available wherever you settled; Italy's advantages are conditional and geographic — the 7% route requires a qualifying small southern town, and the substitute-tax route requires wealth large enough to justify a fixed annual payment. Italy rewards people willing to be specific about where they live.
Asset taxation is the clearest structural difference. Italy charges annually on the value of foreign real estate and foreign financial assets; Portugal does not have an equivalent broad charge on financial assets. For a retiree with a large US portfolio and a retained US house, that recurring Italian cost can exceed the income tax difference between the countries.
Practical life differs more than the tax tables suggest. Portugal's expat infrastructure is deeper and English goes further; Italian bureaucracy is heavier and Italian is close to essential outside the major cities and the north. Both have good public healthcare with regional variation in quality, and in both the access route depends on residence status.
For a US citizen, one thing is constant in both: PFIC rules, FBAR, FATCA and the full US return travel with you, and the local bank in either country will recommend products you should not own. The country choice changes the tax arithmetic; it does not change the structural American problem.
The expensive mistake: Choosing the country on tax and then discovering you dislike living there
The 7% Italian regime requires a small southern municipality, and the regimes that make Portugal cheap have narrowed. People optimise a nine-year tax benefit and commit to a place they would not otherwise have chosen, in a language they do not speak, far from an international airport. The tax difference is usually worth less than a decade spent somewhere you actively want to be.
What to do
- Spend a full off-season month in each shortlisted place — August in Puglia and February in Puglia are different propositions. So are the Algarve and the Alentejo.
- Run both countries with your real portfolio and asset mix — The answer flips depending on how much sits in financial assets and whether you keep a US house.
- Check what happens when the regime expires — Italy's 7% route runs nine years. Plan the position afterwards before you rely on the years before it.
| Factor | Italy | Portugal |
|---|---|---|
| Headline regime | 7% southern route or €200,000 substitute tax, both conditional | NHR withdrawn for new arrivals |
| Annual tax on foreign financial assets | Yes — IVAFE | No broad equivalent |
| Annual tax on foreign property | Yes — IVIE, with relief for foreign property tax | No broad equivalent |
| Geographic constraint | 7% route requires a qualifying small southern comune | None |
| English usage | Limited outside cities and the north | Widespread |
| US obligations | Unchanged | Unchanged |
Sources
- Agenzia delle Entrate — English portal
- Publication 54 — Tax Guide for U.S. Citizens and Resident Aliens Abroad