Home › Ask

How do I know if I can afford to take a pay cut to move?

Short answer: Compare net to net, not gross to gross. Subtract from each side the costs that genuinely change: health insurance and deductibles, childcare, college saving, commuting, and tax. For many American families moving to Europe, a headline salary cut of thirty per cent narrows to a fraction of that once those lines are netted off.

Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.

Why it works this way

Gross salary is the worst possible comparison across countries because it sits above every line that differs. A US package carries costs that are invisible in the number — family health premiums, deductibles, childcare at market rates, and saving for college at US prices.

Tax cuts both ways. Higher marginal rates elsewhere reduce take-home, but public provision replaces spending you were making privately. The net effect is frequently much smaller than the marginal rate suggests, and occasionally positive.

What the comparison cannot capture is what you are buying: time, proximity to family, a different pace, safety, or a childhood you want your children to have. Those belong in the decision explicitly, priced against the number rather than pretending they are free.

The line people forget entirely is retirement saving. A US package often carries an employer match and high contribution limits; the replacement abroad may be more generous, or considerably less. Because that difference compounds for decades, a move that looks neutral on this year's take-home can be materially better or worse by the time you stop working.

Currency belongs in the comparison too. If your savings are in dollars and your new life is priced in euro, your effective pay cut moves with the exchange rate every year — a variable no salary negotiation controls and most comparisons ignore.

The expensive mistake: Comparing this year's package to next year's salary

The US number people quote usually includes bonus, equity vesting and a 401(k) match, while the foreign number is base salary alone. That comparison is not close to fair. Put total compensation against total compensation, including employer pension contributions on the new side.

What to do

  1. Build both household budgets, after tax — Same categories, same currency, honest numbers. One page.
  2. Add employer pension and benefits to the new side — Employer contributions and public provision are compensation, even though they never appear in the salary figure.
  3. Decide what the difference is buying — If there is a genuine gap, name what you are getting for it. That is a decision. Pretending the gap is zero is not.
  4. Test the gap over ten years, not one — A smaller salary usually also means smaller retirement contributions and a slower-growing base. The one-year comparison flatters the move; the ten-year one is the honest test.
Lines that change between a US and a European package — compare these, not the headline salary.
LineTypically in the USTypically in Europe
Family health coverPremiums plus deductibles, paid by youLargely public, with optional private top-up
ChildcareMarket ratesSubsidised in many countries
University savingA major household savings goalFar smaller or negligible
Employer retirement contributionMatch, often cappedVaries widely — ask for the percentage
Paid leaveLimitedStatutory minimum, usually substantial
Commuting and second carOften unavoidableFrequently optional

Related questions

Book a call with Selanis