How do I deal with PFICs before moving back to the US?
Short answer: Sell them before you lose the foreign tax credit that offsets the damage, not after. Foreign funds are PFICs for a US citizen whether you live abroad or at home, and the excess distribution regime keeps accruing interest for every year they are held. The final year of foreign residence is usually the cheapest year to dispose, because local tax on the gain is still available as a credit.
Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.
Why it works this way
The default PFIC regime taxes a gain by spreading it across the whole holding period, applying the highest ordinary rate to the prior years and adding an interest charge. The longer a fund is held, the worse the eventual disposal becomes. Waiting until you are settled at home makes the problem strictly larger, never smaller.
While you are still foreign resident, a disposal usually triggers local capital gains tax — 26% in Italy, 28% in Portugal, 25% plus surcharges in Germany, 19% to 28% in Spain depending on the band. That foreign tax is creditable against the US liability arising on the same disposal in the same year. Sell a month after you land and there is no foreign tax at all, so the US charge stands alone.
There are exceptions worth checking rather than assuming. If the fund is standing at a loss, if the holding period is short, or if the local exit-year rate is unusually high, the calculation can favour holding until after departure. It is a computation, and a small one, but it has to be run per holding rather than as a rule of thumb.
Pension-wrapped funds are a separate question. Foreign funds held inside a recognised pension arrangement are often treated differently from the same funds held in a taxable account, so the clean-up applies to the local brokerage account, the insurance bond, the unit-linked savings plan and the education savings product far more urgently than to the occupational pension.
The expensive mistake: Bringing a local savings plan or insurance bond home to 'deal with later'
Assurance-vie, Portuguese PPRs, Swiss unit-linked plans and Spanish investment funds all keep accruing PFIC interest charges after you return, with no foreign tax left to offset them and an annual Form 8621 for each one. Later is always more expensive here, and the foreign provider is much less responsive once you have a US address.
What to do
- List every non-US fund, bond and savings plan you hold outside a pension — Including anything sold to you by a local bank or an international adviser. Those are the ones that hurt.
- Run the disposal both ways for each holding — Final resident year with local tax and credit, versus first US year with no credit. Then act on the answer, not the instinct.
- Keep the acquisition records before the local platform disappears — Purchase dates, costs and distribution history determine the PFIC computation, and they are far harder to obtain after the account closes.