Home › Ask

Should I use the foreign earned income exclusion or the foreign tax credit?

Short answer: In a high-tax country, the foreign tax credit usually wins: it typically eliminates the US liability anyway, preserves earned income for IRA contributions and child tax credit purposes, and can build carry-forward credits. The exclusion tends to suit low-tax or no-tax countries such as the UAE, where there is no foreign tax to credit.

Written and reviewed by Anthony Walsh, Selanis. Last reviewed 2026-10-06.

Why it works this way

The two reliefs work differently. The exclusion removes a slice of foreign salary from your US taxable income entirely. The credit leaves the income on the return and offsets the US tax with the foreign tax you already paid. Same goal, very different side effects.

The side effects are the whole story. Excluded income is not earned income for IRA purposes, and it can reduce or eliminate the refundable child tax credit. Families with children and a desire to keep funding US retirement accounts frequently lose thousands a year by using the exclusion out of habit.

There is also a switching cost. Revoking the exclusion generally locks you out of re-electing it for a period without permission, so this is not a decision to flip back and forth. It deserves a proper multi-year model at the point of moving, and a review when your country, income or family situation changes.

The expensive mistake: Letting the first-year preparer decide it forever

The election is usually made by whoever filed your first year abroad, often chosen because it produced the simplest return. Six years later nobody has revisited it, the family has two children, and the unclaimed credits add up to a meaningful sum.

What to do

  1. Look up which forms your last returns used — Form 2555 is the exclusion. Form 1116 is the credit. That tells you where you stand.
  2. Model both, including knock-on effects — IRA eligibility, child tax credit, carry-forward credits and future years — not just this year's bottom line.
  3. Check your country's effective rate against US rates — High-tax countries generally favour the credit; low-tax jurisdictions generally favour the exclusion.

Sources

Related questions

Book a call with Selanis